Vision Insurance Claim Denied: How to Appeal Glasses, Contacts, and Eye Surgery Denials

Vision Insurance Claim Denied: How to Appeal Glasses, Contacts, and Eye Surgery Denials

Vision insurance claims — for glasses, contact lenses, eye exams, and surgical procedures — are denied with surprising frequency. Some denials are legitimate (the service isn't covered under your vision plan), but many are not — particularly when eye conditions or procedures are medical in nature and should be covered under your health insurance, not just vision coverage.

Understanding the distinction between vision insurance and medical insurance for eye care is the key to successfully fighting many vision claim denials.

The Vision vs. Medical Insurance Distinction

Vision insurance typically covers:

• Routine eye exams (refraction, prescription check)
• Prescription eyeglasses (frames + lenses)
• Contact lenses (standard soft lenses)
• Discounts on LASIK or other elective vision correction

Medical (health) insurance covers eye care when it involves a medical condition or diagnosis:

• Eye diseases: glaucoma, macular degeneration, cataracts, diabetic retinopathy
• Injuries to the eye
• Conditions like strabismus, amblyopia, or ptosis that require medical treatment or surgery
• Eye infections, inflammation, or other acute conditions
• Visual field testing for neurological conditions

The most common mistake in vision claims: Submitting a claim for a medical eye condition to vision insurance (which won't cover it) instead of medical health insurance (which should).

Common Vision Insurance Denial Reasons

Routine exam frequency limit: Most vision plans cover a routine eye exam once every 12 or 24 months. If you had an exam more frequently, the second claim is denied.

Allowance exceeded for frames/lenses: Vision plans provide a specific dollar allowance for frames and lenses. If your selected frames cost more than the allowance, the overage is denied.

Non-covered service: LASIK, premium contact lenses, and specialty treatments are often excluded from basic vision plans.

Non-network provider: Many vision plans (VSP, EyeMed, Davis Vision, etc.) have preferred provider networks. Using a non-network provider typically results in out-of-network (lower) benefits or denial.

Medical eye condition denied by vision insurer: Your vision insurer denies a claim for a medical condition (e.g., glaucoma treatment, cataract surgery) because it considers these "medical" not "vision" services.

"Cosmetic" classification: LASIK and other elective refractive corrections are classified as cosmetic by most vision and health insurers.

Appealing a Vision Insurance Denial

When Vision Insurance Denies a Routine Vision Claim

For frequency limit denials:

• Verify the exact frequency limit in your plan
• If your exam was within the allowed frequency but the insurer's dates are wrong, provide documentation of the correct dates
• If a medical eye condition required an additional exam within the frequency limit, argue that the additional exam was medically necessary (and should be covered by health insurance, not vision insurance)

For allowance exceeded denials:

• Confirm that the denial covers only the amount exceeding the allowance, not the full claim
• Consider whether medical necessity for specific lens features (anti-reflective coating for post-cataract patients, photochromic lenses for light-sensitive conditions) supports a coverage exception

For network provider denials:

• Verify whether an in-network exception is available (e.g., if you needed care urgently and no in-network provider was available)
• If the provider accepted your insurance at point of service without advising of network status, you may have additional protections

When Medical Eye Conditions Are Denied

Medical eye conditions should be billed to health insurance, not vision insurance. If your vision insurer denied a claim for cataract surgery, glaucoma treatment, or retinal disease treatment:

• Ensure the claim was submitted to your medical health insurer, not just the vision insurer
• Medical eye care claims to health insurers follow the same process as any health insurance denial (medical necessity appeal, external review)

Cataract surgery: Standard cataract surgery is covered by most health insurance plans (including Medicare). Denials typically arise for:

• Premium intraocular lenses (IOLs) — health insurance covers the standard IOL, but premium lenses (multifocal, toric) are considered elective upgrades
• Timing of surgery — the insurer may argue the cataract isn't severe enough yet

For IOL upgrades, the additional cost is typically an out-of-pocket expense. For timing disputes, your ophthalmologist's letter documenting vision impairment meeting coverage criteria is essential.

Glaucoma treatment: Treatment for glaucoma (medications, laser treatment, surgery) is a medical benefit. If denied by your health insurer as "vision," correct the claim submission and resubmit as a medical claim with ICD codes for glaucoma.

LASIK and refractive surgery: Standard LASIK is classified as elective by most insurers. However:

• Some plans with vision benefits include LASIK discounts (not full coverage)
• If LASIK is performed following an eye injury or to correct a medically necessary condition, a medical necessity argument may apply
• Some military and police/fire department plans have LASIK coverage for operational vision requirements

Step-by-Step Appeal for Vision Claims

Step 1: Identify whether this is a vision plan denial or a health insurance denial of a medical eye condition.

Step 2: If it's a medical eye condition denied by vision insurance, resubmit to your health insurer with appropriate ICD-10 medical diagnostic codes (not refractive error codes).

Step 3: If it's a health insurance denial of a medical eye condition (e.g., cataract surgery, glaucoma treatment):

• Obtain a letter from your ophthalmologist documenting the medical necessity
• Reference clinical guidelines (American Academy of Ophthalmology)
• Submit a formal appeal

Step 4: If it's a routine vision plan denial:

• Review the plan's specific terms
• Contact your vision insurer's customer service
• If resolution isn't possible, file a formal complaint

Step 5: Escalate to external review (for medical insurance denials) or your state's Department of Insurance (for vision plan denials).

Children's Vision Coverage

US: Under the ACA, vision care for children under 19 is an Essential Health Benefit. Qualified health plans must cover pediatric vision care — including glasses and routine eye exams — even if they don't cover adult vision care. If your child's vision claim is denied under an ACA-compliant health plan, this may be a violation of the Essential Health Benefits requirement.

Medicaid EPSDT: Children on Medicaid are entitled to eye care (including glasses) as an EPSDT service. Denial of children's vision services under Medicaid is challengeable under EPSDT.

UK Vision Care

In the UK, NHS eye tests are free for:

• Children under 16 (and under 19 in full-time education)
• People 60 and over
• People with diabetes or glaucoma (or at risk of glaucoma)
• People receiving certain benefits

If you are disputing a private health insurance denial for eye care in the UK:

• Check whether your condition is a medical condition covered under your PMI
• For conditions like cataracts, glaucoma, or macular degeneration treated privately, your PMI should cover it as a medical condition
• File a formal complaint with your insurer and escalate to the FOS if unresolved

Conclusion

Vision insurance denials are often straightforward plan limitation issues — but when they involve medical eye conditions, the claim often belongs with your health insurer, not your vision insurer. Understanding this distinction can resolve many "denials" immediately. For genuine health insurer denials of medical eye conditions, the standard medical necessity appeal process applies. Use ClaimBack at claimback.app to generate a professional appeal letter for your vision or eye surgery insurance denial.

---

Related Reading:

• Hearing Aids Denied by Insurance: How to Appeal
• How to Write an Insurance Demand Letter
• Top 10 Insurance Appeal Success Tips
• What If Your Insurance Appeal Is Denied Again?