Property Insurance Claim Denied: Your Rights and How to Fight Back

Property Insurance Claim Denied: Understanding Your Rights and Fighting Back

A denied property insurance claim is financially devastating. Whether it's storm damage, a burst pipe, fire, theft, or structural damage, your home or property represents your most significant asset — and you need your insurer to honor the contract you've been paying premiums on for years.

The reality is that property insurance claims are among the most frequently contested and frequently overturned insurance disputes. Insurers deny and underpay property claims using a predictable set of tactics, and understanding these tactics is the first step toward defeating them.

---

The Most Common Reasons Property Claims Are Denied

Maintenance vs. Sudden Loss

The most common property insurance denial is the insurer categorizing damage as "gradual deterioration," "wear and tear," or "lack of maintenance" rather than a sudden, accidental loss. Property policies typically cover sudden and accidental losses — not gradual decay.

The challenge: Damage is almost never purely one or the other. A roof that has aged is more vulnerable to storm damage. An aging water heater is more likely to fail catastrophically. The question is whether a covered peril (storm, sudden mechanical failure) caused or contributed to the loss — if it did, many jurisdictions require the insurer to cover at least the portion of damage attributable to the covered peril.

Policy Exclusions

Common property insurance exclusions that are frequently contested:

• Flood exclusion: Standard homeowners policies typically exclude flood damage. But if storm surge, roof damage that allowed water entry, or a burst pipe caused the water damage, this may be covered.
• Earth movement exclusion: Excludes earthquake and land settling — but not all ground movement. Tree root damage causing foundation issues, or earth movement caused by a covered event (e.g., construction explosion), may still be covered.
• Mold exclusion: Many policies exclude mold, but if the mold resulted from a covered water event (burst pipe, storm damage), coverage disputes arise over causation.

Inadequate or Missed Damage Assessment

Adjusters working for your insurer have an incentive to minimize the assessed damage. Common problems:

• Missed damage in areas the adjuster didn't inspect thoroughly
• Damage that manifests or is discovered after the initial inspection
• Damage assessed using low repair cost estimates (Xactimate software set to low cost codes)
• Structural damage that requires a structural engineer's assessment, not just a visual inspection

Security Requirements Not Met

Many property policies include conditions — alarm systems, security doors, deadbolts — that must be in place for coverage to apply. If an alarm wasn't activated, or security hardware wasn't installed, the insurer may invoke this to deny the claim.

The key challenge: In many jurisdictions, the insurer can only invoke a policy condition breach if that breach caused or contributed to the loss. If your home was burgled through a back window when you had a required deadbolt on the front door, the deadbolt requirement being met elsewhere may not save the denial — but the causal argument ("did this specific breach cause this specific loss?") is still worth making.

---

Step 1: Understand Your Policy — Replacement Cost vs. Actual Cash Value

This is foundational. Your property policy should clearly state whether it pays:

• Replacement Cost Value (RCV): The cost to repair or replace the damaged property at current market prices, without deduction for depreciation
• Actual Cash Value (ACV): The replacement cost minus depreciation — typically resulting in a significantly lower payment

If your policy says RCV and the insurer is paying ACV, that is an error you should dispute immediately. Check the declarations page and the policy conditions section.

Additionally, many RCV policies require you to complete the repair before claiming the full replacement cost — they pay ACV initially and then pay the "holdback" (the depreciation amount) once you submit repair receipts. Understand this process and follow it to maximize your payment.

---

Step 2: Commission an Independent Contractor's Estimate

Before accepting any insurer's payment or settlement offer, get an independent estimate from a licensed contractor with experience in your type of damage (roofing, water damage, fire restoration, structural repair).

Key points:

• Get two or three independent estimates — consistency across estimates strengthens your position
• Ask the contractor to provide a detailed, itemized scope of work (not just a total number)
• Compare the insurer's estimate to the independent estimates — gaps are the basis of your dispute
• Insurers often use Xactimate at the lowest local cost codes; your contractor can identify where the insurer's estimate is unrealistically low

The gap between the insurer's settlement and an independent contractor's estimate is the number you bring to the dispute table.

---

Step 3: Document Everything

Photograph and video all damage extensively — immediately after the event and throughout the repair process. Specifically:

• Overall shots showing the full extent of damage
• Close-up shots of specific damage points
• Before-and-after shots where prior conditions are known
• Shots of interior and exterior where water intrusion, fire, or other damage spread

Retain all correspondence with the insurer, all adjuster visit notes, and all documents you receive.

---

Step 4: Challenge the Adjuster's Scope and Estimate

Request a copy of the adjuster's scope of loss — the itemized list of what damage they identified and what they estimated for each item. Review it line by line against your contractor's scope.

File a formal written dispute of the scope that includes:

• A list of damage items your contractor identified that the adjuster missed
• A comparison of the insurer's repair costs to your contractor's costs, with explanation of the difference
• Photographs supporting each disputed item
• Your demand for a re-inspection if damage was missed

---

Step 5: Invoke the Appraisal Clause

Most property insurance policies contain an appraisal clause — a mechanism for resolving disputes about the amount of a loss (not whether coverage applies) without litigation. Typically:

1. You demand appraisal in writing (check your policy for how to do this)
2. Both you and the insurer appoint a licensed, independent appraiser within a defined period
3. The two appraisers try to agree on the loss amount
4. If they can't agree, they appoint a neutral umpire — any two of the three agreeing on a number is binding

Appraisal is typically faster and cheaper than litigation. It bypasses the insurer's internal claims department and puts the loss assessment in the hands of construction professionals.

Important: The appraisal clause generally only covers disputes about the amount of the loss, not coverage disputes (e.g., whether a flood exclusion applies). Ensure you are disputing the amount, not the coverage determination, before invoking appraisal.

---

Step 6: File a State/Regulatory Complaint for Bad Faith

If your insurer has denied or underpaid your claim in bad faith — meaning they unreasonably failed to investigate, misrepresented your coverage, or denied claims they knew were valid — you can file a regulatory complaint and potentially pursue bad faith litigation.

By jurisdiction:

• USA: File with your State Department of Insurance. In states like California, Montana, and Washington, strong bad faith statutes allow policyholders to recover damages beyond the policy value for bad faith conduct. An attorney can advise on whether a bad faith claim applies.
• UK: File with the Financial Ombudsman Service. The FCA's requirements for fair claims handling make bad faith conduct a reportable market conduct violation.
• Australia: AFCA handles property insurance disputes. The Insurance Contracts Act 1984's duty of utmost good faith (s.13) creates obligations the insurer must meet.
• Canada: Provincial insurance superintendents handle complaints. Bad faith litigation is available in Canadian courts with meaningful damages.

---

Step 7: Consider a Public Adjuster

A public adjuster is a licensed professional who works for policyholders (not insurers) to assess damage, document losses, and negotiate with the insurer on your behalf. They typically charge a percentage (10–20%) of the final claim settlement.

Public adjusters are particularly valuable when:

• The damage is complex or extensive
• The insurer's initial settlement offer is significantly below your contractor's estimates
• You don't have time to manage the claims process yourself

Studies have found that policyholders who use public adjusters often receive significantly higher settlements than those who negotiate directly.

---

Common Mistakes in Property Insurance Appeals

1. Accepting the adjuster's scope without an independent estimate. The adjuster's estimate is a starting point, not a final answer.

2. Signing a release too quickly. Insurers sometimes present settlement agreements early in the process. Don't sign a release without getting independent estimates first.

3. Not invoking the appraisal clause. This is the fastest path to a higher settlement in amount disputes. Many policyholders don't know it exists.

4. Not documenting damage before beginning emergency repairs. You must make emergency repairs to prevent further damage (most policies require this), but photograph everything before and during repairs.

5. Missing the proof of loss deadline. Most policies require a signed proof of loss document within 60–90 days of the loss. Missing this can void your claim.

6. Not checking whether the "gradual deterioration" denial is really a causation dispute. If a covered peril contributed to the damage, the pure "maintenance" denial may not hold up under scrutiny.

---

Getting Your Property Insurance Appeal Letter Written

A strong property insurance appeal systematically addresses each denial or underpayment reason with specific contractor evidence, policy citations, and the relevant legal arguments. ClaimBack can help you generate a professional appeal letter for property insurance denials tailored to your specific situation and jurisdiction. Visit claimback.app to get started.

---

Summary: Property Insurance Appeal The Full Fight

1. Commission independent contractor estimates before accepting any insurer offer
2. Request the adjuster's full scope of loss and compare line by line
3. Document all damage thoroughly with photographs and video
4. File a formal written dispute of the insurer's scope and valuation
5. Invoke the appraisal clause for amount disputes in your policy
6. File a regulatory complaint for bad faith or procedural violations
7. Consider a public adjuster for complex or high-value claims
8. Don't sign any release until you are satisfied with the settlement amount