Insurance Retroactive Denial: How to Fight Retroactive Claim Rejections

What Is a Retroactive Insurance Denial?

A retroactive insurance denial — also called a rescission — occurs when an insurance company cancels your coverage or denies a claim not from the date you are notified, but backwards in time, effectively voiding coverage that you believed you had when medical services were incurred. The insurer essentially reaches back and erases your policy as if it never existed, leaving you responsible for bills you thought were covered.

Retroactive denials are among the most harmful actions an insurer can take. They typically occur in two forms:

1. Retroactive rescission of the policy itself: The insurer rescinds (cancels) your health insurance policy from a past date — often the start date — citing alleged misrepresentation or non-disclosure in your application. Any claims paid during the rescinded period are then "clawed back," and any unpaid claims are denied.

2. Retroactive denial of individual claims: The insurer approves and pays a claim initially, then later reverses its payment decision and demands the money back — or denies a subsequent related claim based on a retroactive coverage determination.

This guide explains your rights under federal law (primarily the ACA) and state laws, how to challenge retroactive denials, and the timelines that apply.

---

Why Insurers Issue Retroactive Denials

Insurers issue retroactive denials for a variety of reasons — some legitimate, many that can be successfully challenged:

Alleged misrepresentation on the application. The insurer claims you misrepresented or concealed a material fact when applying for coverage — typically a pre-existing medical condition. Before the ACA, this was the primary mechanism for retroactive rescission. Post-ACA, it is significantly restricted.

Fraud. Insurers may rescind coverage where they allege deliberate, intentional fraud in the application. This is distinct from innocent misrepresentation or omission.

Post-payment review. The insurer conducts a medical review after paying a large claim and concludes that coverage should not have applied. This is particularly common for expensive hospital admissions or surgical procedures.

Eligibility retroactive termination. For employer group coverage, retroactive termination of an employee's eligibility (for example, when HR submits termination paperwork late) can create a retroactive denial for claims submitted after the employee left employment.

Non-payment of premiums. If a premium was not received and the policy lapsed before the medical service, the insurer may retroactively deny claims as occurring outside the coverage period.

---

Your Rights Under the Affordable Care Act (ACA)

The ACA dramatically limited insurers' ability to retroactively rescind health insurance coverage in the United States. Under 45 CFR § 147.128 (for individual and small group markets) and implementing regulations:

Rescission is prohibited except in two circumstances:

1. Fraud: The policyholder engaged in fraud — an intentional act of misrepresentation.
2. Intentional misrepresentation: The policyholder intentionally misrepresented material facts on the application. Innocent mistakes, omissions the applicant did not know about, and information the insurer could have verified do not qualify as intentional misrepresentation under ACA standards.

Critically, the ACA bars rescission based on innocent or inadvertent omissions — the pre-ACA practice of combing through medical records to find any discrepancy that could justify cancellation is now prohibited for non-grandfathered plans.

Additionally, the ACA requires:

• 30 days' advance notice before a rescission takes effect, giving the policyholder time to appeal.
• The right to an internal appeal and external review of a rescission decision.

---

State Law Protections Against Retroactive Denials

Many states have enacted additional protections beyond the ACA:

California: California Insurance Code Section 10384 limits rescission to cases of material misrepresentation or fraud, and the California Department of Managed Health Care (DMHC) has aggressively penalized insurers for improper rescissions. California also requires insurers to verify the accuracy of applications at the point of sale rather than rescinding after a large claim arises.

New York: The New York State Department of Financial Services enforces strict anti-rescission rules. New York prohibits rescission entirely for errors or omissions that the insurer could have discovered through reasonable investigation at the time of application.

Texas: The Texas Insurance Code limits retroactive terminations and requires advance notice and appeal rights before a rescission takes effect.

Other states: Most states have adopted rules consistent with or more protective than the ACA. Contact your state insurance department to understand your specific state protections.

---

Step-by-Step: How to Fight a Retroactive Denial

Step 1: Demand a Complete Written Explanation

When you receive notice of a retroactive denial or rescission, immediately request in writing:

• The specific ground for rescission (fraud vs. intentional misrepresentation — these are distinct)
• The specific statements in your application that the insurer claims were false or misleading
• The medical evidence or records the insurer reviewed to reach this conclusion
• A complete copy of your claims file and application file

You are entitled to this information. Without it, you cannot build an effective appeal.

Step 2: Assess the Basis for Rescission

Review the insurer's stated basis carefully:

• Was the alleged misrepresentation truly material? A misrepresentation is only material if it would have led the insurer to deny coverage or charge a different premium had it been disclosed.
• Was it intentional? The ACA only permits rescission for intentional misrepresentation. If you genuinely did not know about a condition (for example, a condition that was undiagnosed at the time you applied), the omission was not intentional.
• Could the insurer have verified the information at the time of application? In many states, an insurer that could have verified the disclosed information through a medical underwriting review but failed to do so cannot retroactively rescind when that information later becomes relevant.
• Is the alleged omission actually related to the claim being denied? Even where misrepresentation occurred, some courts and state regulators require that the undisclosed condition be related to the claim being denied.

Step 3: File a Formal Internal Appeal

Under the ACA, you have the right to appeal a rescission decision through the insurer's internal appeals process. Your appeal must:

• Specifically contest the insurer's characterization of your application statements as intentional misrepresentation
• Provide evidence that any omission was innocent, inadvertent, or related to information you genuinely did not have
• Include medical records demonstrating when the condition was first diagnosed, treated, or known
• Include a declaration from your treating physician if appropriate
• Reference any state law protections applicable in your state

The insurer must provide you with a final internal appeal decision. For urgent medical situations, request expedited review.

Step 4: Request External Review

Following a final internal denial, you are entitled to external review of a rescission decision by an Independent Review Organization (IRO). For rescissions specifically, many states allow you to request external review even before completing internal appeals. The IRO's decision on whether the rescission was lawful under the ACA and state law is binding on the insurer.

Step 5: File with Your State Insurance Department

File a formal complaint with your state insurance department describing the retroactive denial or rescission. State regulators take rescission complaints seriously, particularly post-ACA. Provide:

• The insurer's rescission notice
• Your internal appeal and the insurer's response
• All supporting documentation showing the alleged omission was not intentional

State regulators can investigate, order the insurer to reinstate coverage retroactively, and impose penalties.

Step 6: Legal Action

For high-value retroactive denials, consider engaging an insurance bad faith attorney. Many states impose significant penalties — including punitive damages and attorney's fees — on insurers that rescind coverage in bad faith. Attorney's fees provisions can make legal action financially viable even for mid-sized claims.

---

Retroactive Denials in Employer Group Plans

For employer-sponsored ERISA plans, ACA rescission protections still apply. However, the enforcement mechanism is different: ERISA complaints are handled by the Department of Labor (DOL), not state insurance departments.

If your employer retroactively terminated your health coverage (for example, after a termination of employment), and claims were denied for services you received while you believed you were still covered:

• File a complaint with the DOL's Employee Benefits Security Administration (EBSA) at dol.gov/agencies/ebsa
• Contact EBSA's helpline: 1-866-444-EBSA (3272)
• EBSA provides free assistance to ERISA plan participants

---

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Not responding to the rescission notice within the 30-day window. The ACA requires 30 days' notice before a rescission takes effect. Use this window to file an expedited internal appeal and, if applicable, an external review request.

Assuming rescission is legitimate. Many rescissions are unlawful under the ACA. Do not assume the insurer is right.

Paying retroactively clawed-back amounts without contesting. If your insurer demands repayment of previously paid claims following rescission, contest this through the appeals process before making any payment.

Not understanding COBRA implications. If your coverage is rescinded, you may have COBRA continuation rights. Consult with the Department of Labor or an attorney to understand your options.

---

Use ClaimBack to Draft Your Appeal

Challenging a retroactive denial or rescission requires a precisely written appeal letter that correctly applies ACA standards and state law protections. ClaimBack at claimback.app helps you generate a professional, legally-grounded appeal letter tailored to your specific rescission or retroactive denial situation. A well-constructed letter dramatically improves your chances of success at both the internal appeal and external review stages.

---

Conclusion

Retroactive insurance denials and rescissions are among the most egregious actions an insurer can take — but they are not unbeatable. The ACA has dramatically restricted when rescissions are lawful, most states have additional protections, and the combination of internal appeals, external review, state regulatory complaints, and legal action gives you powerful tools to fight back. Act within the 30-day pre-rescission window, gather evidence that your omission was not intentional, and use every available channel. For a professional appeal letter, start with ClaimBack at claimback.app.