Dental Claim Denied by Insurance: When and How to Appeal

Dental work is expensive. That's why you have dental insurance. But when you submit a claim, you often get a denial: "Cosmetic procedure, not covered" or "Not medically necessary" or "Waiting period hasn't expired."

Don't accept these denials at face value. Many dental insurance denials are reversible—you just need to know how to challenge them.

Why Dental Insurance Denies Claims

Understanding the specific reason behind your denial is your starting point.

Cosmetic vs. Medically Necessary Classification

This is the most common dental denial. Insurance classifies certain procedures as cosmetic (not covered) versus medically necessary (covered). But the line is often blurry.

Examples of disputed classifications:

• Teeth whitening: Usually cosmetic, but sometimes medically necessary after root canal to match other teeth
• Orthodontics: Often classified as cosmetic, but sometimes medically necessary for functional bite problems, TMJ issues, or sleep apnea
• Dental implants vs. bridges: Insurance may prefer cheaper bridges, but implants can be medically necessary if you can't tolerate removable dentures
• Gum surgery: May be denied as cosmetic (especially if cosmetic in appearance), but is medically necessary if needed to treat periodontal disease or preserve teeth
• Veneers: Often classified as cosmetic, but can be medically necessary after trauma or if needed to restore function

Your appeal should argue that the procedure is medically necessary, not just cosmetic.

Waiting Periods Not Met

Many dental plans exclude coverage for certain procedures during the first 6-12 months (sometimes longer for major work like crowns or implants). If you claim too early, automatic denial. But waiting period denials are rigid—difficult to appeal unless you can show exceptional circumstances.

Pre-Existing Condition Exclusions

Some dental plans exclude coverage for conditions that existed before you enrolled. If your dentist says you need a crown because of a cavity that was there before enrollment, insurance may deny based on pre-existing exclusion. Challenge this by:

• Showing that the condition worsened or became acute after enrollment
• Showing that the need for treatment arose after enrollment
• Getting your dentist to document when the problem actually required treatment

Missing Pre-Authorization

Many dental procedures require pre-authorization. If your dentist didn't request pre-auth and you get billed after treatment, insurance may deny. Challenge this by:

• Asking the dentist to request pre-auth retroactively
• Arguing that you weren't informed pre-auth was required
• Showing that your dentist informed insurance of the procedure in advance

Frequency Limitations

Dental plans often limit certain procedures (cleanings, X-rays, fluoride treatments) to a set number per year. If you exceed the limit, claims are denied. But sometimes more frequent treatment is medically necessary (for example, patients with gum disease often need more frequent cleanings).

Argue medical necessity: "Due to [specific condition], more frequent treatment is medically necessary."

Exceeding Annual Maximums

Many dental plans cap annual benefits (e.g., $1,000 per year). Once you hit the cap, insurance denies further claims for the year. This is harder to appeal unless you can show:

• You weren't informed of the annual maximum
• The cap is unreasonably low (though insurers will resist this argument)
• Emergency treatment should be exempted from the cap

Getting Your Dentist to Support Your Appeal

Your dentist is your strongest advocate. They must explain why the denied procedure is medically necessary.

Schedule a Discussion

Call your dentist's office and explain the denial. Ask: "Will you help me appeal this claim? I need a letter explaining why this procedure is medically necessary."

Most dentists will help. This is part of their practice—communicating with insurance on behalf of patients.

What Should the Letter Include?

Ask your dentist to specifically address the insurance company's stated reason for denial.

If insurance said it's cosmetic: "This procedure is not cosmetic. It is medically necessary because [specific clinical reason]. Without this treatment, the patient faces [specific consequence: tooth loss, infection, functional impairment]."

If insurance said frequency exceeds plan limits: "While the plan limits routine cleanings to X times per year, this patient has [specific clinical condition] that requires more frequent treatment. More frequent cleanings are medically necessary to prevent [tooth loss, infection, disease progression]."

If insurance said pre-existing exclusion applies: "While this condition may have existed before enrollment, treatment is medically necessary now because [specific reason explaining why treatment is urgent NOW, not before]."

If insurance said pre-auth wasn't obtained: "I provided documentation of this treatment plan to the patient's insurance, or the treatment was emergency care necessitated by [specific acute problem]."

Get a Second Opinion If Needed

If your dentist is reluctant to write a strong appeal letter, get a second opinion from another dentist. Many dental specialists (periodontist, prosthodontist, orthodontist) will write a letter supporting the necessity of a referred patient's treatment.

Challenging Cosmetic vs. Medically Necessary Classifications

This is the most common dental appeal, and here's how to win it.

Understand How "Medically Necessary" is Defined

Ask your insurance company in writing: "What is your definition of medically necessary for dental procedures? What criteria do you use to distinguish cosmetic from medically necessary?"

Most insurers will provide a definition. Once you have it, read carefully for:

• Situations where cosmetic procedures become medically necessary
• Emphasis on functional benefit
• Language suggesting flexibility

Show Functional Benefit

Insurance cares about function and health, not appearance. Frame your appeal around function, not cosmetics:

Don't say: "I want my teeth to look better" Do say: "This treatment is necessary to restore chewing function" or "This treatment prevents tooth loss" or "This treatment treats periodontal disease"

Your dentist should explain the functional benefit in their letter.

Provide Clinical Evidence

If you had trauma, infection, or disease:

• Get imaging (X-rays, CT scans)
• Get clinical photographs
• Get your dentist's clinical notes
• Show any pain or functional impairment

Clinical evidence makes clear that treatment is medically necessary, not cosmetic.

Use Policy Language

Quote your actual dental policy. Look for language that supports coverage. For example, if the policy covers treatment for "disease prevention" or "restoration of function," use this language in your appeal. If the policy says "cosmetic only when the appearance is the sole purpose," argue that appearance is not the sole purpose in your case.

Building Your Dental Appeal Letter

Structure your appeal to be clear and persuasive.

Opening

"I am appealing [Insurance]'s denial of coverage for [specific procedure] on [date]. I believe this denial was based on an incorrect determination that the procedure is cosmetic rather than medically necessary."

Your Clinical Situation

Describe your specific dental problem:

• When did it start?
• What symptoms or functional problems are you experiencing?
• What have you tried so far?
• Why does your dentist recommend this specific treatment?

Make it clear that this is a clinical problem, not a cosmetic one.

Why It's Medically Necessary, Not Cosmetic

Explain:

• What disease or condition requires treatment
• What functional impairment or health risk exists without treatment
• Why this specific procedure is the appropriate treatment
• What consequences would occur if treatment is delayed

Addressing Insurance's Specific Stated Reason

If insurance said:

"Cosmetic procedure": Explain why it's medically necessary. "While this procedure may have cosmetic aspects, it is medically necessary because [specific clinical reason]. The primary purpose is [functional restoration/disease treatment/pain management], not appearance."

"Exceeds frequency limits": "While the plan allows X procedures per year, my condition requires more frequent treatment. My dentist has documented that [specific reason], making more frequent treatment medically necessary."

"Pre-existing condition": "While this condition may have existed before enrollment, it did not require treatment then. Treatment is medically necessary now because [specific reason]. The acute need for treatment arose after enrollment."

Enclosed Evidence

List all attached documents:

• Your dentist's letter supporting medical necessity
• X-rays or imaging
• Clinical photographs
• Your dentist's clinical notes
• Any specialist letters (periodontist, prosthodontist, etc.)
• Your policy documents
• Any other relevant clinical documentation

Closing

"Based on [dentist]'s clinical documentation that this procedure is medically necessary, I request that [Insurance] reverse this denial and approve coverage."

Timeline: Know Your Deadlines

• Appeal deadline: Usually 90-180 days from denial (check your policy)
• Dentist's response: Ask your dentist to send the letter within 1-2 weeks
• Insurance response time: Usually 15-30 days for dental claims

File your appeal immediately. Don't wait.

When to Escalate Beyond Insurance

If insurance denies your appeal:

• Escalate to your state's insurance commissioner (USA)
• Escalate to your country's financial regulator
• Ask your dentist if they'll accept the insurance decision or work with you on payment

Getting Help With Your Dental Appeal

Dental insurance appeals require specific clinical framing. The key is presenting your situation as a medical/functional problem, not a cosmetic one. Your dentist's support is critical, but framing the argument effectively is what wins appeals.

ClaimBack's AI analyzes your dental insurance denial, helps you frame the medical necessity argument, organizes your evidence, and drafts a compelling appeal letter your dentist will support. You review, edit, and submit it—maintaining full control.

Get your free dental appeal analysis →

---

Disclaimer: ClaimBack provides AI-generated appeal assistance for informational purposes only. ClaimBack is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. Always review your appeal letter before sending and consider professional advice for complex or high-value claims.

Ready to fight your denial? Start your free claim analysis →