Autism / ABA Therapy Insurance Claim Denied: How to Appeal

Autism / ABA Therapy Insurance Claim Denied: How to Appeal

Applied Behaviour Analysis (ABA) therapy is the most clinically validated treatment for autism spectrum disorder (ASD) in children and adults. Despite overwhelming clinical evidence supporting ABA therapy, insurance companies routinely deny claims for ABA therapy, occupational therapy, speech therapy, and other autism-related services on grounds including medical necessity, age limitations, benefit caps, and "educational" vs. "medical" treatment distinctions.

If your insurer has denied coverage for autism-related therapy, you have powerful rights to fight back — including state autism insurance mandate laws in the United States that may legally require your insurer to cover ABA.

Why Autism Therapy Claims Are Denied

"Not medically necessary" denial: The most common denial. Your insurer's clinical reviewer determines the therapy doesn't meet their medical necessity criteria, often without reviewing sufficient clinical documentation or in reliance on internal criteria that don't reflect current science.

Benefit cap reached: Many plans cap ABA therapy at a certain number of hours per week or a maximum annual dollar amount. Once the cap is reached, claims are denied.

"Educational" vs. "medical" treatment reclassification: Some insurers deny ABA therapy claims arguing the therapy is "educational" or "habilitative" (teaching new skills) rather than "medical" (rehabilitating lost function), placing it outside covered medical benefits. This distinction is legally contested in many US states.

Prior authorisation not obtained or not renewed: Many plans require prior authorisation for ABA therapy — often annually or semi-annually. If the authorisation lapses or is not renewed, ongoing claims are denied.

Provider credentials not met: Insurers may dispute whether the ABA therapist's credentials (BCBA, RBT) meet the plan's credentialing requirements.

Step therapy or "less intensive" treatment required: Some insurers require less intensive (cheaper) treatments before authorising intensive ABA therapy.

"Developmental condition" exclusion: Some older plans exclude developmental conditions from coverage. This exclusion is increasingly challenged by state autism mandates and parity laws.

US State Autism Insurance Mandates

This is the most powerful tool available to US autism families: All 50 US states and Washington DC have passed autism insurance mandate laws requiring health insurance plans to cover ABA therapy and other autism treatment services. However, the specifics vary significantly by state:

• Most state mandates apply to fully-insured commercial health plans
• Self-insured ERISA plans (common at large employers) are exempt from state mandates
• Many states have age limits (often 18 or 21) and annual benefit caps (ranging from $36,000 to unlimited)
• Some states require all evidence-based autism treatment without specifying ABA

To use your state's autism mandate:

1. Verify that your plan is fully insured (check your Summary Plan Description or ask HR)
2. Research your specific state's autism mandate coverage requirements (Autism Speaks at autismspeaks.org maintains state-by-state resources)
3. Cite the specific mandate in your appeal letter
4. File a complaint with your state's Department of Insurance if the insurer ignores the mandate

The Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act (MHPAEA)

Federal MHPAEA law prohibits health insurers from imposing more restrictive limits on mental health benefits (which may include ASD treatment) than on comparable medical/surgical benefits. This means:

• If your plan has no annual visit limit for physical therapy, it cannot impose a visit limit for ABA therapy
• If your plan covers medical services until no longer necessary, it must do the same for ABA therapy
• If your plan uses different medical necessity criteria for mental health services than for medical services, this may violate MHPAEA

MHPAEA arguments are powerful and frequently upheld in appeals and external reviews.

Step-by-Step: Appealing an Autism Therapy Denial

Step 1: Read the Denial Letter Carefully

Your insurer's denial notice should specify:

• The exact reason for denial (medical necessity, benefit cap, prior authorisation, etc.)
• The clinical criteria or plan provision relied on
• Your right to appeal

Step 2: Gather Comprehensive Clinical Documentation

The single most important factor in winning an ABA therapy appeal is comprehensive, well-documented clinical evidence:

• Detailed treatment plan from a Board Certified Behaviour Analyst (BCBA): The plan should specify current deficits, treatment goals, the number of hours recommended per week, and the evidence base for this intensity.
• Physician's letter: From your child's developmental paediatrician, psychiatrist, or neurologist confirming the autism diagnosis and supporting the recommended therapy intensity as medically necessary.
• Functional behaviour assessment (FBA): Documents current behavioural challenges and their impact on daily functioning.
• Progress reports: If the child is already receiving ABA and the insurer is trying to reduce hours or terminate coverage, progress reports showing ongoing clinical need are essential.
• Independent expert opinion: If the insurer ordered an independent medical review, obtain a rebuttal from your BCBA or treating physician.

Step 3: Address the Specific Denial Ground

For medical necessity denials:

• Your appeal must directly address the insurer's clinical criteria
• Cite the US Surgeon General's report on mental health, American Psychological Association, American Academy of Paediatrics, and other major clinical bodies supporting ABA as the evidence-based treatment for ASD
• Demonstrate that your child's specific deficits require the intensity of treatment recommended

For benefit cap denials:

• Argue that MHPAEA prohibits applying caps to ABA therapy that would not apply to comparable medical treatment
• Cite your state's autism mandate if it specifies unlimited or higher coverage amounts

For prior authorisation issues:

• Request an expedited review if the denial of authorisation is urgent
• Submit the full clinical documentation supporting the requested treatment hours

For "educational" vs. "medical" reclassification:

• Argue that ABA therapy is medically necessary treatment for a diagnosed medical condition (ASD is listed in DSM-5) regardless of whether it also confers educational benefits
• Cite case law and regulatory guidance that treat ABA as medical treatment

Step 4: Submit Your Appeal Letter

Include all supporting documentation and specifically invoke:

• Your state's autism mandate (if applicable and your plan is fully insured)
• MHPAEA (if the denial applies more restrictive limits to autism treatment than to medical treatment)
• The full body of clinical evidence supporting ABA therapy

Step 5: Request External Review

After exhausting internal appeals, request external review by an Independent Review Organisation (IRO). For autism-related denials, request that the IRO reviewer have expertise in developmental disabilities or behavioural health.

External review success rates for autism denials are high — external reviewers are much more likely than internal insurer reviewers to apply current clinical science rather than restrictive internal criteria.

Step 6: File a State Insurance Complaint

File with your state's Department of Insurance simultaneously with your appeal, particularly if:

• Your insurer appears to be violating your state's autism mandate
• Your insurer is applying MHPAEA restrictions unlawfully

Step 7: Contact Advocacy Organisations

The following organisations provide free assistance for autism insurance disputes:

• Autism Speaks (autismspeaks.org) — insurance toolkit and state-by-state resources
• Association for Behaviour Analysis International (ABAI) — resources for BCBA credentialing disputes
• Your state's Protection and Advocacy (P&A) organisation — free legal assistance for disability-related issues

Common Mistakes in Autism Therapy Appeals

Submitting insufficient clinical documentation: A brief letter from your paediatrician is not enough. The appeal needs a detailed BCBA treatment plan, functional assessment, and specific clinical justification for the recommended hours.

Not invoking MHPAEA: Many ABA denials violate MHPAEA. If you're not citing this law, you're missing a powerful tool.

Accepting "observation" hours as equivalent to ABA: Some insurers try to substitute "observation only" or "monitoring" hours for full ABA treatment. This is not clinically equivalent.

Not requesting an IRO with expertise in developmental disabilities: Generic external reviewers may not have the expertise to evaluate ABA claims appropriately.

Conclusion

Insurance denials for autism ABA therapy are common, but they are frequently overturned — especially when state mandates apply, when MHPAEA is invoked, and when the appeal includes comprehensive clinical documentation. Don't accept an ABA therapy denial without fighting back. Use ClaimBack at claimback.app to generate a professional appeal letter for your autism therapy insurance denial.

---

Related Reading:

• Mental Health Residential Treatment Denied: How to Appeal
• How to Negotiate with Your Insurance Company
• Can You Sue Your Insurance Company?
• Insurance Bad Faith: Your Rights When an Insurer Wrongfully Denies